Birth, death, and the finality of the Match
What was most amazing about the showing though, was the panel discussion afterward with a midwife, a nurse, a researcher, a doula, an OB and a family doctor. It was one of those moments when I realized that I have lived in this town for a long time (9 years!) and i do know people in this community, even though I feel like an outsider most of the time.
The midwife said some nice things about the importance of surgical birth, and helped to calm the crowd who seemed to be about to eat the OB. She also said smart stuff about how all health professionals work from our own experience, and that choosing a profession has much to do with our own experiences of birth. Which I read as "you will not change the opinions of the obstetrician by logical arguments or passionate defenses of your positions -- she is not just defending her job, but also her own family, and her choices as a mother. Her role in her own family will trump the arguments of strangers, every time."
Which impressed me a lot. This was the same midwife who pissed me off during our prenatal class when MamaM was pregnant. At the time, she insisted that babies were all conceived in love and privacy, and needed their mother and father to be in a similar environment for their birth. She was so adamant that most of the other people in our class were embarrassed on our behalf and kept trying to correct her. It was very awkward at the time.
I didn't know the nurse or the researcher, so I can't give you any back story! But the nurse did mention that there were no nurses in the film, and that nurses can be helpful in a birth too! True enough, although in the states, most midwives are nurses first.
The OB was fascinating. I am totally impressed that she showed up at all, as not many people there were kindly disposed towards her to say the least. eek. She did throw the word "natural" around a whole lot, and only got heckled a few times. I was impressed when she said that she supports drug-free labours in hospitals. Which I believe, although I have also seen several births with her, and been on-call with her. I very clearly remember one night when a woman who had come in with a doula and was being followed by the family medicine team was labouring. The family med resident (who was probably 25) checked her, and was heading off - when the OB insisted that she rupture the woman's membranes. The resident refused, saying that because the woman didn't have an epidural, it would be unnecessarily painful, and she was progressing well. The OB retorted that the rooms were nearly full, and around here it is "active management of labour." To her extreme credit, the very junior resident put her foot down and said "she's my patient, and i am not rupturing her yet." Gah.
I liked what the doula had to say. I'd seen her around the hospital, but hadn't really heard her speak before. She made a good argument for having a doula for anyone who wants one, which would certainly improve outcomes for most women.
But what totally impressed me were the things that the family doctor had to say. I am entirely not objective on this point because 1) LittleE was born with a midwife and a family doctor in attendance and 2) This particular doctor has been a huge role model for me over the past 4 years. Every time that woman speaks, i learn something.
I remember 3 births with her: One was a c-section, which she attended just to be with her patient, which was awesome. The second was a baby who was born flat, and didn't start breathing on her own. She caught the baby, and placed her on the mom's belly for some skin-to-skin time. And at the point where all the other people in the room were about to burst, she calmly picked up the baby, and softly explained that she needed to give her a bit of air to perk her up. All was well, and the parents never knew that things hadn't gone absolutely perfectly. The third was a woman who was all alone, and spoke neither english nor french. I'd spent most of the day with her (and was mocked by the OB residents, but whatever, I don't really know what I'm *supposed* to be doing, so I just get the work done, and then do what I want to learn). I'd stayed late because she told me I could do the baby catching part. The woman had progressed very well until the epidural, and then slowed right down. She was pushing and pushing and wasn't getting anywhere. The baby had crowned, but was stuck, and his heart rate started dropping. She took the bold step of cutting the cord before the baby was born. Everything turned out well, but it could have been a huge disaster. The cord was wrapped around the baby's neck, and was too short for him to clear the vagina, and too short for it to be slipped over his head either.
After it was all over, the mom was breastfeeding well, and I was doing the repair of her smallish tear. This doctor was still a bit shaky after the near miss.
And she hugged my head.
Which was an excellent acknowlegement of our shared mortality and the significance of the day we had all spent together - the mother, an amateur translator (who really worked in sterilization or medical records or something), me, and this kick-ass doctor. I was really late getting out that night. (coincidentally, it was the night that we were meeting with the spuncle to ask him if he'd be willing to help us out in the procreation department another time).
And what totally impressed me the other night was that she mentioned death. Several times. And she was the only one who did. All of the other people in that room were either young women, or professionals who work solely with moms and babies. She was the only one who regularly sees death.
She pointed out that in the 1600's, when "natural birth" was the only choice, 1/10 women and 4/10 babies died in childbirth or shortly afterwards.
And I really think that it's an important dimension in the conversation about natural birth.
For a couple of reasons. Like, if having a natural home birth is difficult to arrange these days, a natural home death is often even harder. Another doctor I like a lot (Balfour Mount) gave a lecture to us, and pointed out that in the 1600's death was the province of women and children. Women were responsible for the rituals around death, and they and their children were who did most of the dying. Now it's old people who do most of the dying. And we can hide death by hiding age. If we stay young, we cannot die. But that is such a silly line of thinking. We are all dying. Each of us has the same number of deaths that all of our ancestors had. There's 1 each. Life is risky, and it will end. Not dying is not a reasonable goal. Preventing death may be possible in the short term, but is no way to live an entire life.
At some point, living needs to be valued above not dying.
A lot of the criticism of home birth is about the risk of death for both mother and baby. Birth is risky. Living is risky. People die. I am absolutely not saying that 1/10 mortality rate is acceptable, there is certainly a role for surgical birth and other birth interventions. But for many women, what is to be gained in having a birth on their own terms is worth the risk. It is a milestone that will prepare them for the task of parenting ahead. Give them the experience necessary to teach their children what it is to take risks, and make decisions in an uncertain world in awareness of their own mortality.
There is a fellow in my medskool class who does a lot of wild mountain biking. And was adamant that his wife would give birth in a hospital. I couldn't help but wonder if she would insist that he save his biking for the stationary bikes at the gym. After all - he would get the same fitness benefit, and not constantly risk head injury and his surgeon's hands!
At the end of the night, someone in the audience asked what family doctors do and don't do. She explained that 50% of women in Canada are followed by FP's for their pregnancy. She explained that she doesn't do cesarean sections, and that the best part of family doctors is that they can follow these babies, sometimes into adulthood, and journey with families from womb to tomb.
I know that I chose right about what to do next year.
epilogue: ran into the doctor outside the show, and she asked me where i'd matched. I told her. She punched my arm and said "f*ck you." Which was the perfect compliment.


